MOKGORO J
the Court appeared to be willing to defend the statute in its present form.
[54]
The consensus fostered by these concessions affords this Court the opportunity to
adjudicate this matter on the basis of overbreadth analysis, without reaching the issues of (a)
whether the Legislature may, consistent with the new Constitution, regulate sexually explicit
material at all; and, (b) if so, what form of definition of proscribed sexually explicit material will
pass constitutional muster. As to the first issue, I propose to simply assume, for purposes of this
matter, an answer in the affirmative. As to the second, for purposes of overbreadth analysis I need
not attempt to formulate a constitutionally permissible definition.
[55]
Applicants did not dispute, for purposes of the application before us, that the contents of
the various video cassettes found in their possession were in fact covered by the definition of
“indecent or obscene” matter. If that be so, it does nothing to negate the Act’s overbreadth, since
it is not necessary for a successful overbreadth challenge that the conduct of the actual litigant in
the case before the Court fall within the zone of overbreadth. 90 If the law itself is overbroad, it has
to go, and no conviction may be founded upon it. That is so because of the chilling effect that
overbroad legislation may have, discouraging others from engaging in constitutionally protected
activities because legislation which on its face prohibits such activity remains on the statute
books 91.
Under United States law, if a statute not only forbids expressive conduct that may
constitutionally be restricted, but also forbids constitutionally protected expression, courts will
look beyond the facts immediately before it to determine whether a putative class of future
90
See, e.g., R v Canadian Pacific Ltd., [1995] 99 C.C.C. (3d) 97.
91
Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario v Rocket, [1990] 71 D.L.R. (4th) 68.
31
Sélectionner le paragraphe cible3
Se connecter à un paragraphe
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Ajouter à la table des matières