ZONDI AJ
consequences of the ambiguity created by the law as at the time of conviction. The
evidence adduced at the trial established that Mr Masiya was guilty of indecent assault.
To convict him of rape would be in violation of his right as envisaged in section 35(3)(l)
of the Constitution. I conclude therefore that the developed definition should not apply
to Mr Masiya.‖48 (Footnotes omitted.)
[63]
In Savoi this Court held that the rule against retrospectivity was no longer a tool
of interpretation but rather constituted a fundamental right not to be subjected to
retrospective provisions.49
[64]
The High Court, relying on Bothma,50 held that an accused‘s right to a fair trial
would be no more prejudiced in a prosecution after 20 years for sexual offences, than
his rights in a prosecution after 20 years for rape or compelled rape. This conclusion
was predicated on a finding that rights to a fair trial, coupled with the state‘s discretion
on whether to prosecute based on the cogency and reliability of the evidence at its
disposal, would serve to reduce any prejudice an accused person might have
experienced as a result of a delay in prosecution beyond 20 years.51
[65]
I agree with the High Court‘s conclusion.
On the facts presented by the
applicants, Mr Frankel could have been prosecuted for the common law offence of
indecent assault as that was the crime at the time it was committed. The declaration of
invalidity of section 18 does not therefore give rise to a new act which was not unlawful
at the time it was committed.
Remedy
[66]
It remains to consider an appropriate remedy. The constitutional invalidity of
section 18 arises from that portion which bars, in all circumstances, the right to institute
48
Masiya above n 19 at paras 54 and 56-7.
49
Savoi v National Director of Public Prosecutions [2014] ZACC 5; 2014 (5) SA 317 (CC); 2014 (5) BCLR 606
(CC) at para 78.
50
Bothma above n 15 at para 82.
51
High Court judgment above n 2 at paras 81-3.
27
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات