ZONDI AJ
[39]
The TBC contends that there is a higher duty to protect children in failed systems
of care facilities, places of safety, and insular communities, as they face the risk of being
harmed in such places. It points out that in many instances survivors are coerced into
silence by the perpetrator and the community or the facility may prevent them from
speaking due to their dependency for care.
The TBC argues that prescription on
prosecution of sexual offences does a disservice to society as it promotes secondary
violation and victimisation of the most vulnerable groups by not allowing justice to be
seen to be done.
Sixth respondent’s submissions
[40]
LHR submits that the 20-year period is in itself arbitrary and irrational, as it has
been adopted from Roman-Dutch law principles – codified in the 17th century – and
the fact that the period has not changed over centuries is indicative of the arbitrary
development of the contents of section 18. It further argues that there is no genuine
rationale for this period within modern constitutional criminal law, as the usual
justification for prescription in criminal cases is the availability of clear and best
evidence which is often not relevant to the prosecution of sexual offences. It reasons
that in the absence of physical evidence, the prosecution of sexual offences simply relies
on the testimony of the complainant and alleged offender. In turn, where there is
physical evidence, there is then no need for the 20-year prescription period in light of
technological advances in forensics and evidence gathering. The LHR therefore
contends that it would be ―absurd‖ to have a serial sexual offender escape criminal
liability, where there is clear evidence (such as DNA evidence) linking the perpetrator
to the offence, because a period of 20 years has lapsed.
Is section 18 irrational and arbitrary?
[41]
Before dealing with the irrationality and arbitrariness of section 18, it is
necessary to say something about its historical development.
17
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات