FRONEMAN J
that may, however, legitimately be assessed in determining the primary wrongfulness
of the conduct of the state, through its officials, in a delictual action based on direct
liability.
Wrongfulness in delict
[117] The development of wrongfulness as a criterion for determining the boundaries
of delictual liability found its primary input in Minister van Polisie v Ewels.40 In that
case the then Appellate Division found that our law had reached the stage of
development where an omission is regarded as unlawful conduct when the
circumstances of the case are of a nature that the legal convictions of the community
demand that the omission should be considered wrongful.41 This open-ended general
principle has since evolved into the general criterion for establishing wrongfulness in
all cases, not only in omission cases.42
40
1975 (3) SA 590 (A) (Ewels).
41
Id at 597A-C.
42
See Administrateur, Natal v Trust Bank van Afrika Bpk 1979 (3) SA 824 (A) at 833A (Administrateur, Natal);
Minister of Safety and Security v Van Duivenboden 2002 (6) SA 431 (SCA) (Van Duivenboden) at para 12;
Gouda Boerdery BK v Transnet 2005 (5) SA 490 (SCA) (Gouda) at para 12; Two Oceans above n 36 at paras
10-2; Stewart and Another v Botha and Another 2008 (6) SA 310 (SCA) at para 7; McIntosh v Premier,
Kwazulu-Natal and Another 2008 (6) SA 1 (SCA) at para 12; Brooks v Minister of Safety and Security 2009 (2)
SA 94 (SCA) at para 5; Fourway Haulage SA (Pty) Ltd v SA National Roads Agency Ltd 2009 (2) SA 150
(SCA) (Fourway Haulage) at para 12; and Freddy Hirsch Group (Pty) Ltd v Chickenland (Pty) Ltd 2011 (4) SA
276 (SCA) at para 38. See also Du Bois ―Getting Wrongfulness Right: a Ciceronian Attempt‖ in Scott & Visser
(eds) Developing Delict: Essays in Honour of Robert Feenstra (Juta, Cape Town 2000); Fagan ―Rethinking
Wrongfulness in the Law of Delict‖ (2005) 122 SALJ 90; Du Bois ―State Liability in South Africa: A
Constitutional Remix‖ above n 2; and Price ―The Impact of the Bill of Rights on State Delictual Liability for
Negligence in South Africa‖, paper presented at the ‗Obligations V Conference: Rights and Private Law‘, St
Anne‘s College, Oxford University (2010).
47
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات