I agree on the conviction of the first convict. However, I see that the punishment
against him was lenient, as he is the father of the second convict’s husband, and
who is expected to be more protective of her than others.
As for the second convict, I am of the opinion to cancel the punishment against
her, as her criminal act was forced on her by someone of influence, and might have
been overwhelmed by shock over [the action of] the first convict, as she wouldn’t
have expected the action to come from her husband’s father; since she was alone
with him, and she even resisted and deplored the action, which means she was
forced.
Mostafa Abdulgadir Awadulkarim
Suprme Court Justice
9/1/2015
Final Decision;
1- We uphold the appealed-against ruling by majority.
2- We cancel the request and notify the parties.
Mostafa Abdulgadir Awadalkarim
Supreme Court Justice
And
Head of the Circuit
9/1/2015.
3