O’REGAN J and SACHS J
The Supreme Court gave weight to the disruption likely to result from the striking of old
laws having significant social value in the present, and allowed them to survive despite
their constitutionally questionable origins.
[111] Similar to the United States and Canada, where social transformation has at different
times rendered obsolete the motivation underlying existing legislation, South Africa is
undergoing a metamorphosis.
But ours is one of far greater magnitude than that ever
experienced by either of our North American counterparts.
As Mohamed DP said in
Shabalala:69
“It retains from the past only what is defensible and represents a radical and decisive
break from that part of the past which is unacceptable . . . The past was pervaded by
inequality, authoritarianism and repression. The aspiration of the future is based on what
is ‘justifiable in an open and democratic society based on freedom and equality’.”
As part of this transformation, all legislation incompatible with our new constitutional
order is invalid.70
69
Shabalala and Others v Attorney-General of Transvaal and Another 1996 (1) SA 725 (CC); 1995 (12)
BCLR 1593 (CC) at para 26.
70
See section 229 of the interim Constitution which provides that “Subject to this Constitution, all laws which
immediately before the commencement of this Constitution were in force in any area which forms part of
the national territory, shall continue in force in such area, subject to any repeal or amendment of such laws
by a competent authority.”; and item 2 of schedule 6 of the final Constitution which provides that “(1) All
law that was in force when the new Constitution took effect, continues in force, subject to – (a) any
amendment or repeal; and (b) consistency with the new Constitution. (2) Old order legislation that
continues in force in terms of subitem (1) – (a) does not have a wider application, territorially or otherwise,
than it had before the previous Constitution took effect unless subsequently amended to have a wider
application; and (b) continues to be administered by the authorities that administered it when the new
Constitution took effect, subject to the new Constitution.” See also, the supremacy clause in section 2 of
the 1996 Constitution: “This Constitution is the supreme law of the Republic; law or conduct inconsistent
with it is invalid, and the obligations imposed by it must be fulfilled.”
76
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents