I agree with the conclusion reached by my colleague Dr. Ahmed to uphold the decision issued by the Court of Appeal to quash the judgment and to refer the case back to be reconsidered in accordance with the different reasons stated in the pleading and to reject/quash the appeal on summary basis and appellant shall bear the respective fees. Al Bushra Osman Salih, “signed” Judge at the Supreme Court 06/08/2015 Dr. Sitana Abdel Galil “signed” Judge at the Supreme Court 20/08/2015 Final Order: To uphold the contested judgment by referring the case back to the Trial Court to proceed in accordance with the different reasons stated and to reject/quash the appeal on summary basis and the appellant shall bear the respective fees. Al Bushra Osman Salih, “signed” Judge at the Supreme Court 23/08/2015